We assessed the effects and dynamics of firms in three specific areas: employment creation, working conditions and skill development of local workers (i.e. workers from the countries receiving these firms). Our project is centred around individual worker-level interviews as they enable us to develop a dynamic and comparative picture of the employment conditions of African workers in these settings. For example, the workers interviewed were asked about their previous employment so that comparisons could be drawn with their current conditions. We conducted both quantitative surveys and qualitatively focused in-depth interviews. The former were used to give us a detailed picture of the sectors in question and let us draw direct comparisons between industries and ownership structures, while the latter gave us insights into the effects of employment on individual workers’ lives. Of particular concern across all interviews was the effect of employment in manufacturing and construction on training and general skill development, especially for unskilled workers who came from rural areas and agricultural occupations.
Summary of data collection instruments and samples
Data collection instrument | Angola | Ethiopia | Period |
---|---|---|---|
Workers survey (main questionnaire) | 682 | 839 | Angola: Sept 2016-March 2017 Ethiopia: March-Sept 2017 |
Firm management survey | 34 | 40 | Angola: March 2017- July 2018 Ethiopia: January – August 2018 |
Life/Work histories | 23 | 33 | Angola: March 2017- April 2017 Ethiopia: October– December 2017 |
Qualitative research – other SSIs | 98 | 117 | Angola: November 2015- July 2018 Ethiopia: November 2015 – August 2018 |
Phone survey (follow-up) | 126 | 155 | Angola: October – December 2018 Ethiopia: September- November 2018 |
The quantitative surveys targeted workers at leading manufacturing and construction companies in both Ethiopia and Angola. We carefully selected the firms in each sector based on size and reputation. Workers in each company were selected using stratified random sampling, and interviews were conducted by skilled and experienced interviewers, who underwent an intense training programme for this specific project. In total, we conducted over 680 workers’ interviews in Angola and 840 workers’ interviews in Ethiopia. The distribution of sampled of workers and firms by sector and origin of firm is summarised below.
Combined sample of firms by sector and firm origin (both countries)
Manufactoring | Construction | Total | |
---|---|---|---|
CHINESE firms | 16 | 15 | 31 |
OTHER FOREIGN firms | 14 | 8 | 22 |
DOMESTIC firms | 12 | 11 | 23 |
TOTAL | 42 | 34 | 76 |
Combined sample of workers by sector and firm type
Manufacturing | Construction | Total | |
---|---|---|---|
CHINESE firms | 313 | 287 | 600 |
OTHER FOREIGN firms | 285 | 180 | 465 |
DOMESTIC firms | 238 | 218 | 456 |
TOTAL | 836 | 685 | 1521 |
Qualitative research
Qualitative research proceeded in different stages, from an exhaustive scoping process preceding the quantitative surveys, to follow-up qualitative research focused on life histories of workers and in-depth interviews with a range of relevant respondents, including firm managers, site/factory supervisors, policy makers and implementers, relevant experts, trade union representatives, and other relevant stakeholders. We conducted over 200 qualitative interviews distributed as follows:
Qualitative interviews
Category | Ethiopia | Angola |
---|---|---|
Government | 27 | 19 |
Firms | 72 | 69 |
Trade union | 9 | 4 |
International Orgs | 6 | 5 |
NGO | 3 | 1 |
TOTAL | 117 | 98 |